Some of the most haunting and moving voices of the Pali canon are
those that resonate through the fragmentary poems of the theris or
nuns of early Buddhism. That these fragmentary verses have been
preserved and included in the Buddhist doctrinal canon indicate that
nuns were considered an intrinsic part of the sangha in the early
years of Buddhism. Tessa Bartholomeusz describes the transformations
and vicissitudes the order of Buddhist nuns has undergone in Sri
Lanka, home of Theravada Buddhism. It is a fascinating story of
transformation, innovation, and female resilience, responding
necessarily to the political and social pressures of a constantly
changing context. The most innovative feature of twentieth-century
female asceticism was the institution of nunneries for "lay nuns," or
the dasa sil matavo. The book is in two parts. Part 1 covers the
period up to the twentieth century: the establishment of an order of
nuns in the third century BCE, its demise, for reasons not yet known,
around the 12th century CE, the Buddhist revival at the end of the
nineteenth century, and the attempts to revive the lost order of nuns.
One of the fine ironies of the colonial situation was that it was
western theosophists and educators like Colonel Olcott who fuelled the
nationalist Buddhist revival in Sri Lanka against Christianity and
their western colonial counterparts; and it was a westerner, the
Countess Miranda de Souza Canavarro, that Anagarika Dharmapala invited
to reestablish the order of Buddhist nuns in Sri Lanka. Although the
Countess's "nunnery" did not survive long, the idea of female
renunciates serving the cause of Buddhism caught on, and several
innovative moves resulted. By the early twentieth century, Sinhala
Buddhist women had set up the institution of "lay nuns" (dasa sil
matavo). These were not bhikkhunis or the female counterparts of
ordained Buddhist monks, these were lay renunciates who, either as
individuals or in small groups, decided to follow a life of Buddhist
asceticism. The second part of the book deals with some of the
organizations set up by these lay renunciates, the "nunneries" they
established, their innovative methods of ordination, their dress and
rules of conduct, and their perceptions of their role as "lay nuns."
Most of the Sinhala lay nuns accept the fact (rigidly held by a large
section of the ordained monks) that since the Theravada order of nuns
died out there can never be the necessary quorum of nuns required by
the vinaya rules to start the order again. However, they do not
consider this an obstacle to fulfilling their roles as female
renunciates. In fact, their present situation frees them from the
control of monks (laid down in the vinaya rules of the canon), and
gives them independence, autonomy, and a sense of power. As lay nuns
or dasa sil matavo, they can evolve their own rules of conduct, create
their own rituals of ordination, and yet be part of the larger
tradition of Buddhist asceticism. It is in that sense a very creative
and innovative form of feminine resistance, worked out within the
Buddhist framework. There may be little or no consensus among the
different groups of lay renunciates on many issues, such as the
appropriate rituals and rites of passage for the novices, but the
groups agree on the basic premise that in accordance with Buddhist
doctrine, women can, if they so choose, give up their traditional
social roles and adopt the life of a renunciate. Most of the lay nuns
whom Bartholomeusz describes chose the life of the renunciate. Like
their forbears in the Pali canon, they did so because a personal
tragedy, disillusion with the world, a deep religious fervor, or a
commitment to service in the cause of Buddhism led them to renounce
the worldly life. Bartholomeusz also traces the shifts and changes in
lay attitudes toward these renunciates. During the Buddhist revival
the lay nuns had considerable support from elite social groups who
were also spearheading the movement for political independence. But
once independence was won, Buddhism was "restored," and the need for
female participation in Buddhist activities became less politically
important, elite support for the movement declined. The ideal of the
female renunciate has, however, captured the imagination of women from
the rural areas, and their participation has created significant
changes in the movement. These renunciates are less involved in
personal salvation through meditation, but -- like their counterparts,
the gramavasin (village-dwelling) monks -- they believe in a life of
service to their fellows, perform pujas and rituals such as chanting
pirit for the laity, or engage in preaching and teaching. With the
waning of elite involvement, the social standing of the lay nuns also
changed. They still get a fair amount of support and respect in the
villages, but without the earlier visibility and influential political
support they are seen by the general public as marginalized
individuals and, unlike monks, as having no special niche or status in
the larger society. Yet this has not deterred women from becoming
renunciates. On the contrary, Bartholomeusz records that between 1989
and 1992 their numbers increased considerably. The push to acquire
ordination and recognition as bhikkunis or nuns who are members of the
sangha, comes, ironically, from the foreign nuns who feel the need
for such acceptance most. Bartholomeusz documents their various
organizations as well as the ordination ceremonies performed,
(predictably) in America. Tessa Bartholomeusz's Women Under the Bo
Tree contains a fund of information for scholars and students of
Buddhism. The life histories of several of the present day Sri Lankan
lay nuns that she documents provide rich insights into the
personalities of the individuals concerned, their contributions to the
movement, and the sociopolitical and feminist implications of their
institution. The reader might wish the book had leas of a textbook
format where each chapter is framed by an introduction and a
conclusion. However, in focusing attention on an important segment of
Buddhist society -- female renunciates, who though often neglected by
male historians, both lay and clerical, have yet continued to surface
throughout Buddhist history -- this book serves an important function.