Chương VII. Phần phụ lục
Kathvatthu
II.1
1. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
-Atthi Arahato rgo kmargo kmargapariyu hnaµ kmaragasa��ojanaµ kmogho kmayogo kmacchadan´varaöan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe-
-N’atthi Arahato rgo kmargo kmargapariyu hnaµ kmargasa��ojanaµ kmogho kmayogo kmacchadan´varaöan ti ?
-îmant
-Ha�ci n’atthi Arahato rgo kmargo kmargapariyu hnaµ kmargasa��ojanaµ kmogho kmayogo kmacchadan´varaöan, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti.”
2. Atthi puthujjanassa asucisukkavisa hi, atthi tassa rgo kmargo kmargapariyu hnaµ kmaragasa��ojanaµ kmogho kmayogo kmacchadan´varaöan ti ?
-îmant.
-Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa hi, atthi tassa rgo kmargo kmargapariyu hnaµ –pe– kmacchadan´varaöan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa hi, n’atthi tassa rgo kmargo kmargapariyu hnaµ –pe– kmacchadan´varaöan ti ?
-îmant
-Atthi puthujjanassa asucisukkavisa hi, n’atthi tassa rgo kmargo kmargapariyu hnaµ –pe– kmacchadan´varaöan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
3. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
-Ken’atthenti ?<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[1]<!--[endif]--> Handa hi Mrakyik devat Arahato asucisukkavisa hiµ<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[2]<!--[endif]--> upasaµharant´ti.
- Mrakyik devat Arahato asucisukkavisa hiµ upasaµharant´ti ?
- îmant.
- Atthi Mrakyiknaµ devatnaµ Arahato asucisukkavisa hiµ upasaµharant´ti ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- N’atthi Mrakyiknaµ devatnaµ asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
- îmant.
- Ha�ci n’atthi Mrakyiknaµ devatnaµ asucisukkavisa hi, no vata re vattabbe “Mrakyiknaµ devatnaµ Arahato asucisukkavisa hiµ upasaµharant´ti”.
4. Mrakyik devat Arahato asucisukkavisa hiµ upasaµharant´ti ?
-îmant.
- Mrakyik devat attano asucisukkavisa hiµ upasaµharanti, a��esaµ asucisukkavisa hiµ upasaµharanti, tassa asucisukkavisa hiµ upasaµharant´ti ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Mrakyik devat n’ev’attano na a��esaµ na tassa asucisukkavisa hiµ upasaµharant´ti ?
- îmant.
- Ha�ci Mrakyik devat n’ev’<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[3]<!--[endif]--> attano na a��esaµ na tassa asucisukkavisa hiµ upasaµharanti, no vata re vattabbe “Mrakyik devat Arahato asucisukkavisa hiµ upasaµharant´ti”.
5. Mrakyik devat Arahato asucisukkavisa hiµ upasaµharant´ti ?
-îmant.
-Lomakupehi upasaµharant´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Mrakyik devat Arahato asucisukkavisa hiµ upasaµharant´ti ?
-îmant.
-Kiµkraö ti ? Handa hi vimatiµ ghayissmti<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[4]<!--[endif]-->.
Atthi Arahato vimat´ti ?
-îmant.
-Atthi Arahato Satthari vimat´ti, Dhamme vimat´ti, Saµghe vimat´ti, sikkhya vimat´ti, pubbante vimat´ti, aparante vimat´ti, pubbantparante vimat´ti, idappaccayatpa iccasamupannesu dhammesu vimat´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-N’atthi Arahato Satthari vimat´ti, Dhamme vimat´ti, Saµghe vimat´ti, sikkhya vimat´ti, pubbante vimat´ti, aparante vimat´ti, pubbantparante vimat´ti, idappaccayatpa iccasamupannesu dhammesu vimat´ti ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci n’atthi Arahato Satthari vimat´ti–pe–idappaccayatpa iccasamupannesu dhammesu vimati, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato vimat´ti.”
6. Atthi puthujjanassa vimati, atthi tassa Satthari vimat´ti –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamupannesu dhammesu vimat´ti ?
-îmant.
-Atthi Arahato vimat´ti, atthi tassa Satthari vimat´ti –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamupannesu dhammesu vimat´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Atthi Arahato vimat´ti, n’atthi tassa Satthari vimat´ti –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamupannesu dhammesu vimat´ti ?
-îmant.
Atthi puthujjanassa vimati, n’atthi tassa Satthari vimat´ti –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamupannesu dhammesu vimat´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
7. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
-Arahato asucisukkavisa hi kissa nissando ti ? Asitapitakhyitasyitassa nissando ti.
-Arahato asucisukkavisa hi asitapitakhyitasyitassa<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[5]<!--[endif]--> nissando ti.
-îmant.
-Ye keci asanti, pivanti, khyanti, syanti, sabbesa��eva atthi asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Ye keci asanti, pivanti, khyanti, syanti, sabbesa��eva atthi asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant
-Drak asanti, pivanti, khyanti, syanti, atthi draknaµ asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Paö¶k asanti, pivanti, khyanti, syanti, sabbesa��eva atthi paö¶aknaµ asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Dev asanti, pivanti, khyanti, syanti, sabbesa��eva atthi devatnaµ asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
8. Arahato asucisukkavisa hi asitapitakhyitasyitassa nissando ti ?
-îmant.
- Atthi tassa sayo ti ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Arahato uccrapassvo asitapitakhyitasyitassa nissando, atthi tassa sayo ti ?
- îmant.
- Arahato asucisukkavisa hi asitapitakhyitasyitassa nissando, atthi tassa sayo ti ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Arahato asucisukkavisa hi asitapitakhyitasyitassa nissando, n’atthi tassa sayo ti ?
- îmant.
- Arahato uccrapassvo asitapitakhyitasyitassa nissando, n’atthi tassa sayo ti ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
9. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
-Arah methunaµ dhammaµ pa iseveyya, methunaµ<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[6]<!--[endif]--> dhammaµ uppdeyya, puttasambdhasayannaµ ajjhvaseyya, ksikacandanaµ paccanubhaveyya, mlgandhavilepanaµ dhreyya, jtarèparajataµ sdiyeyyti?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Atthi puthujjanassa asucisukkavisa hi, puthujjano methunaµ dhammaµ pa iseveyya, methunaµ dhammaµ uppdeyya –pe–j tarèparajataµ sdiyeyyti?
-îmant.
-Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa hi, Arah methunaµ dhammaµ uppdeyya, methunaµ dhammaµ uppdeyya –pe– jtarèparajataµ sdiyeyyti?
-îmant.
-Atthi puthujjanassa asucisukkavisa hi, na ca puthujjano methunaµ dhammaµ pa iseveyya, methunaµ dhammaµ uppdeyya puttasambdhasayannaµ ajjhvaseyya, ksikacandanaµ paccanubhaveyya, mlgandhavilepanaµ dhreyya, jtarèparajataµ sdiyeyyti?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
10. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu Arahato rgo pah´no ucchinnamèlo tlvatthukato anabhvaµkato yatiµ anuppdadhammo ti ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci Arahato rgo pah´no ucchinnamèlo tlvatthukato<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[7]<!--[endif]--> anabhvaµkato yatiµ anuppdadhammo, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti.”
- Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant
-Nanu Arahato doso pah´no –pe– moho pah´no, mno pah´no, di hi pah´n, vicikicch , th´naµ pah´n, uddhaccaµ pah´naµ –pe–anottappaµ pah´naµ ucchinnamèlaµ tlvatthukataµ anabhvaµkataµ yatiµ anuppdadhamman ti?
-îmant
-Ha�ci Arahato anottappaµ pah´naµ ucchinnamèlaµ tlvatthukataµ anabhvaµkataµ yatiµ anuppdadhammaµ no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti.”
11. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito ti ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti.”
Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu Arahato rgappahnya satipa hn bhvit –pe–sammappadhn bhvit, iddhpad bhvit, indriy bhvit, bal bhvit –pe– bojjhang bhvit ti ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci Arahato rgappahnya bojjhang bhvit, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti.”
12 .Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu Arahato dosappahnya –pe– mohappappahnya–pe–anottappappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit ti ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhang bhvit, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti.”
13. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu Arahato v´targo<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[8]<!--[endif]--> v´tadoso v´tamoho katakaran´yo ohitabhro anuppattasadattho parikkkh´öabhavasa��ojano sammada�� vimutto ukkhittapaligho saµkiööaparikho abbuÂhesiko<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[9]<!--[endif]--> niraggaÂo<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[10]<!--[endif]--> ariyo pannaddhajo pannabhro vis��utto suvijitavijayo, dukkhaµ tassa<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[11]<!--[endif]--> pari��taµ, samudayo pah´no, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhvito, abhi��eyyaµ abhi��taµ, pari��eyyaµ pari��taµ, pahtabbaµ pah´naµ, bhvetabbaµ bhvitaµ, sachiktabbaµ sacchikatan ti?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci Arahato v´targo v´tadoso v´tamoho katakaran´yo –pe– achiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti.”
14, Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti ? Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi asucisukkavisa hi, paradhammakusalassa Arahato n’atthi asucisukkavisa h´ti.
- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi asucisukkavisa h´ti
-îmant.
- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato atthi asucisukkavisa h´ti
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato n’atthi asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
- îmant.
- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato n’atthi asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- 15. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pah´no, atthi tassa asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
- îmant.
- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pah´no, atthi tassa asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no, moho pah´no–pe–anottappaµ pah´naµ, atthi tassa asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappaµ pah´naµ, atthi tassa asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
16. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit –pe– dosappahnya –pe– mohappahnya–pe–anottappappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit, atthi tassa asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahnya, bojjhang bhvit, atthi tassa asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
17. Sadhammakusalo Arah v´targo v´tadoso–pe–sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, atthi tassa asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
-Paradhammakusalo Arah v´targo v´tadoso–pe–sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, atthi tassa asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
18. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pah´no, n’atthi tassa asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pah´no, n’atthi tassa asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no –pe–moho pah´no–pe–anottappaµ pah´naµ, n’atthi tassa asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappaµ pah´naµ, n’atthi tassa asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
19. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit –pe– dosappahnya –pe– mohappahnya –pe– anottappappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit, n’atthi tassa asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhang bhvit n’atthi tassa asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
20. Sadhammakusalo Arah v´targo v´tadoso–pe–sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, n’atthi tassa asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
-Sadhammakusalo Arah v´targo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, n’atthi tassa asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
21. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa h´ti ?
-îmant.
-Anu vuttaµ Bhagavat－ “Ye te Bhikkhave bhikkhè puthujjan s´lasampann satisampajn<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[12]<!--[endif]--> niddaµ okkamanti, tesaµ asuci na muccati. Ye pi te Bhikkhave bhirak<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[13]<!--[endif]--> isayo kmesu v´targ, tesaµ pi asuci na muccati. A hnaµ etaµ Bhikkhave anavakso, yaµ <!--[if !supportFootnotes]--> [14]<!--[endif]-->Arahato asuci mucceyyti.” Atth’eva suttanto ti ?
-îmant.
-Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Arahato atthi asucisukkavisa h´ti”
22. Na vattabbaµ “Arahato atthi asucisukkavisa h´ti”
-îmant.
- Anu Arahato c´varapiö¶aptasensanagilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhraµ pare upasaµhareyyun ti ?
- îmant.
Hi�ci Arahato c´varapiö¶aptasensanagilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhraµ pare upasaµhareyyuµ, tena vata re vattabbe “Arahato atthi asucisukkavisa h´ti”
23. Arahato c´varapiö¶aptasensanagilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhraµ pare upasaµhareyyun ti, atthi Arahato parèpahro ti.?
-îmant.
- Arahato sotpattiphalaµ v sakadgmiphalaµ v angmiphalaµ v arahattaµ v pare upasaµhareyyun ti ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
Parèpahrakath.
______________________________
II. 2
1. Atthi Arahato a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
-Atthi Arahato avijj avijjogho avijjyogo avijjnusayo avijjpariyu hnaµ avijjsa��ojanaµ avijjn´varaöan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-N’atthi Arahato avijj avijjogho avijjyogo avijjnusayo avijjpariyu hnaµ avijjsa��ojanaµ avijjn´varaöan ti ?
-îmant.
- Hi�ci n’atthi Arahato avijj –pe– avijjn´varaöaµ, no vata re vattabbe “atthi Arahato a��öan ti.”
2. Atthi puthujjanassa a��öaµ, atthi tassa avijj avijjogho avijjyogo avijjnusayo avijjpariyu hnaµ avijjsa��ojanaµ avijjn´varaöan ti ?
-îmant.
- Atthi Arahato a��öaµ, atthi tassa avijj avijjogho avijjyogo avijjnusayo avijjpariyu hnaµ avijjsa��ojanaµ avijjn´varaöan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
3. Atthi Arahato a��öaµ, n’atthi tassa avijj –pe– avijjn´varaöan ti ?
-îmant.
-Atthi puthujjanassa a��öaµ, n’atthi tassa avijj –pe– avijjn´varaöan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
4. Atthi Arahato a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
-Arah a��öapakato pöaµ haneyya, adinnaµ diyeyya, mus bhaöeyya, pisuöaµ bhaöeyya, pharusaµ bhaöeyya, samphappalapeyya, sandhiµ chindeyya, nillopaµ hareyya, ekagrikaµ<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[15]<!--[endif]--> kareyya, paripanthe ti heyya, paradraµ gaccheyya, gmaghtaµ kareyya, nigamaghtaµ kareyyti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Atthi puthujjanassa a��öaµ, puthujjano a��öapakato pöaµ haneyya, adinnaµ diyeyya –pe– nigamaghtaµ kareyyati ?
-îmant.
-Atthi Arahato a��öaµ, Arah a��öapakato pöaµ haneyya, adinnaµ diyeyya –pe– nigamaghtaµ kareyyati ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
5. Atthi Arahato a��öaµ, na ca Arah a��öapakato pöaµ haneyya, adinnaµ diyeyya –pe– nigamaghtaµ kareyyati ?
-îmant.
- Atthi puthujjanassa a��öaµ, na ca puthujjanassa a��öapakato pöaµ haneyya, adinnaµ diyeyya –pe– nigamaghtaµ kareyyati ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
6. Atthi Arahato a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
- Atthi Arahato Satthari a��öaµ, Dhamme a��öaµ, Saµghe a��öaµ, sikkhya a��öaµ, pubbante a��öaµ, aparante a��öaµ, pubbantparante a��öaµ, idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu a��öan ti ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- N’ atthi Arahato Satthari a��öaµ, Dhamme a��öaµ, Saµghe a��öaµ, sikkhya a��öaµ, pubbante a��öaµ, aparante a��öaµ, pubbantparante a��öaµ, idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
- Ha�ci n’ atthi Arahato Satthari a��öaµ, Dhamme a��öaµ, Saµghe a��öaµ –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu a��öaµ, no vate re vattabbe “atthi Arahato a��öan ti.”
7. Atthi puthujjanassa a��öaµ, atthi tassa Satthari a��öaµ, Dhamme a��öaµ, Saµghe a��öaµ –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
-Atthi Arahato a��öaµ, atthi tassa Satthari a��öaµ, Dhamme a��öaµ, Saµghe a��öaµ –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu a��öan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Atthi Arahato a��öaµ, n’ atthi tassa Satthari a��öaµ, Dhamme a��öaµ, Saµghe a��öaµ –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
-Atthi puthujjanassa a��öaµ, n’ atthi tassa Satthari a��öaµ, Dhamme a��öaµ, Saµghe a��öaµ –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu a��öan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
8. Atthi puthujjanassa a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu Arahato rgo pah´no ucchinnamèlo tlvatthukato anabhvaµkato yatiµ anuppdadhammo ti ?
-îmant.
- Ha�ci Arahato rgo pah´no ucchinnamèlo tlvatthukato anabhvaµkato yatiµ anuppdadhammo, no vate re vattabbe “atthi Arahato a��öan ti.”
- Nanu Arahato doso pah´no –pe– moho pah´no –pe– anottappaµ pah´nam ucchinnamèlaµ tlvatthukataµ anabhvaµkataµ yatiµ anuppdadhamman ti ?
- îmant.
- Ha�ci Arahato anottappaµ pah´nam ucchinnamèlaµ tlvatthukataµ anabhvaµkataµ yatiµ anuppdadhammaµ, no vate re vattabbe “atthi Arahato a��öan ti.”
9. Atthi Arahato a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit ti ?
-îmant.
- Ha�ci Arahato rgappahnya bhvit, no vate re vattabbe “atthi Arahato a��öan ti.”
Atthi Arahato a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
- Nanu Arahato dosappahnya –pe– anottappappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit ti ?
- îmant.
- Ha�ci anottappappahnya bojjhang bhvit, no vate re vattabbe “atthi Arahato a��öan ti.”
10. Atthi Arahato a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu Arah v´targo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikatan ti ?
-îmant.
- Ha�ci, Arah v´targo –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, no vate re vattabbe “atthi Arahato a��öan ti.”
11. Atthi Arahato a��öan ti ? Sadhammakusalassa Arahato n’ atthi a��öan ti.
- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi a��öan ti ?
- îmant.
-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato n’ atthi a��öan ti.
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
12. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pah´no, atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
- îmant.
- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pah´no, atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no, moho pah´no–pe– anottappappaµ pah´naµ, atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappaµ pah´naµ, atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
13. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit, atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit, atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato dosappahnya –pe– anottappappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit, atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappanya bojjhang bhvit, atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
14. Sadhammakusalo Arah v´targo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
Paradhammakusalo Arah v´targo –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
15. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pah´no, n’ atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pah´no, n’ atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no –pe– anottappappaµ pah´naµ, n’ atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no –pe– anottappappaµ pah´naµ, n’ atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
16. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit –pe–anottappappahnya maggo bhvito –pe–bojjhang bhvit, n’ atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhang bhvit, n’ atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Paradhammakusalo Arah v´targo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, n’ atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
-Sadhammakusalo Arah v´targo –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, n’ atthi tassa a��öan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
17. Atthi Arahato a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
- Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－ “Jnatvhaµ<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[16]<!--[endif]--> Bhikkhave passato savnaµ khayaµ vadmi, no ajnato no apassato. Ki� ca<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[17]<!--[endif]--> Bhikkhave jnato kiµ passato savnaµ khayo hoti ? Iti rèpaµ, rèpaµ, iti rèpassa samudayo, iti rèpassa atthangamo<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[18]<!--[endif]-->; iti vedan –pe– iti sa�� –pe– iti saµkhr –pe– iti vi��öaµ, iti vi��öassa samudayo, iti vi��öassa atthangamo ti. Evaµ kho Bhikkhave jnato evaµ passato savnaµ khayo hot´ti.” Atth’eva suttanto ti ?
-îmant.
-Tena hi na vattabbaµ ‘Atthi Arahato a��öan ti”
18. Atthi Arahato a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
- Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－ “Jnatvhaµ Bhikkhave passato savnaµ khayaµ vadmi, no ajnato no apassato. Ki� ca Bhikkhave jnato kiµ passato savnaµ khayo hoti ? Idaµ dukkhan ti Bhikkhave ajnato apassato savnaµ khayo hoti, ayaµ dukkhasamudayo ti jnato passato savnaµ khayo hoti, ayaµ dukkhanirodhagmin´pa ipad ti jnato passato savnaµ khayo hoti. Evaµ kho Bhikkhave jnato evaµ passato savnaµ khayo hot´ti.” Atth’eva suttanto ti ?
-îmant.
-Tena hi na vattabbaµ ‘Atthi Arahato a��öan ti”
19. Atthi Arahato a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－ “Sabbaµ Bhikkhave anabhijnaµ aparijnaµ avirjayaµ appajahaµ abhabbo dukkhkkhyya. Sabba� ca kho Bhikkhave abhijnaµ parijnaµ virjayaµ pajahaµ bhabbo dukkhakkhyyti” Atth’eva suttanto ti ?
-îmant.
-Tena hi na vattabbaµ ‘Atthi Arahato a��öan ti”
20. Atthi Arahato a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－
“Sah v’assa dassanasampadya<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[19]<!--[endif]-->
Tayas su<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[20]<!--[endif]--> dhamm jahit bhavanti
Sakkyadi hi vicikicchita� ca
S´labbataµ vpi ca vippamutto
Catèh’ apyehi ca vippamutto
Cha cbhi hnni<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[21]<!--[endif]--> abhabbo ktun ti”.
-Atth’eva suttanto ti ?
-îmant.
-Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato a��öan ti” ?
21. Atthi Arahato a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－
-Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－ “Yasmiµ Bhikkhave samaye ariyasvakassa virajaµ v´tamalaµ dhammacakkhuµ udapdi, ‘yaµ ki�ci samudayadhammaµ sabban taµ nirodhadhamman ti,’ saha dassanuppd Bhikkhave ariyasvakassa t´öi sa��ojaöni pah´yanti, sakkyadi hi vicikicch s´labbataparmso ti.” Atth’eva suttanto ti”
-îmant.
Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato a��öan ti” ?
22. Na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato a��öan ti”
-îmant.
-Nanu Arah i hipurisnaµ<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[22]<!--[endif]--> nmagottaµ na jneyya, maggmaggaµ na jneyya, tiöaka havanappat´naµ<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[23]<!--[endif]--> nmaµ na jneyyti ?
23. Arah i hipurisnaµ nmagottaµ na jneyya, maggmaggaµ na jneyya, tiöaka havanappat´naµ nmaµ najneyyti atthi Arahato a��öan ti ?
-îmant.
-Arah sotpattiphalaµ v sakadgmiphalaµ vgmiphalaµ v arahattaµ v na jneyyti ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
A��öakath.
____________________________________
II. 3
1. Atthi Arahato kankh ti ?
-îmant.
- Atthi Arahato vicikicch vicikicchpariyu hnaµ vicikicchsa��ojanaµ vicikicchn´varanan ti ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- N’atthi Arahato vicikicch vicikicchpariyu hnaµ vicikicchsa��ojanaµ vicikicchn´varanan ti ?
- îmant.
- Ha�ci n’atthi Arahato vicikicch vicikicchpariyu hnaµ vicikicchsa��ojanaµ vicikicchn´varanaµ, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato kankh ti” ?
- 2. Atthi puthujjanassa kankh, atthi tassa vicikicch vicikicchpariyu hnaµ vicikicchsa��ojanaµ vicikicchn´varanan ti ?
-îmant.
-Atthi Arahato kankh, atthi tassa vicikicch vicikicchpariyu hnaµ vicikicchsa��ojanaµ vicikicchn´varanan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
3.Atthi Arahato kankh, n’atthi tassa vicikicch vicikicchpariyu hnaµ vicikicchsa��ojanaµ vicikicchn´varanan ti ?
-îmant.
-Atthi puthujjanassa kankh, n’atthi tassa vicikicch vicikicchpariyu hnaµ vicikicchsa��ojanaµ vicikicchn´varanan ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
4. Atthi Arahato kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Atthi Arahato Satthari kankh, Dhamme kankh, Saµghe kankh, sikya kankh, pubbante kankh, aparante kankh, pubbantparante kankh, idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu kankh ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-N’atthi Arahato Satthari kankh, Dhamme kankh, Saµghe kankh, sikya kankh, pubbante kankh, aparante kankh, pubbantparante kankh, idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci n’atthi Arahato Satthari kankh, Dhamme kankh, Saµghe kankh –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu kankh, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato kankh ti”
5. Atthi puthujjanassa kankh, atthi tassa Satthari kankh, Dhamme kankh, Saµghe kankh –pe–idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Atthi Arahato kankh, atthi tassa Satthari kankh, Dhamme kankh, Saµghe kankh –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu kankh ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Atthi Arahato kankh, n’atthi tassa Satthari kankh, Dhamme kankh, Saµghe kankh –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Atthi puthujjanassa kankh, n’atthi tassa Satthari kankh, Dhamme kankh, Saµghe kankh –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu kankh ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
6. Atthi Arahato kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu Arahato rgo pah´no ucchinnamèlo tlvatthukato anabhavaµkato yatiµ anuppdadhamma, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato kankh ti”
-Nanu Arahato doso pah´no –pe– moho pah´no –pe– anottappaµ pah´naµ ucchinnamèlaµ tlvatthukataµ anabhvaµkataµ yatiµ anuppdadhamman ti ?
-îmant.
- Ha�ci Arahato anottappaµ pah´naµ ucchinnamèlaµ tlvatthukataµ anabhvaµkataµ yatiµ anuppdadhammaµ, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato kankh ti.”
7. Atthi Arahato kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit ti ?
-îmant.
- Ha�ci Arahato rgappahnya bojjhang bhvit, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato kankh ti.”
-Atthi Arahato kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu Arahato dosoppahnya –pe– anottappappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit ti ?
-îmant.
- Ha�ci anottappappahnya bojjhang bhvit, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato kankh ti.”
8. Atthi Arahato kankh ti ?
-îmant.
- Nanu Arah v´targo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikatan ti ?
-îmant.
- Ha�ci Arah v´targo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato kankh ti.”
9. Atthi Arahato kankh ti ? Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi kankh, Paradhammakusalassa Arahato n’atthi kankh ti.
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato atthi kankh ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
Paradhammakusalassa Arahato n’atthi kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato n’atthi kankh ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
10. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pah´no, atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-îmant.
- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pah´no, atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no, moho pah´no –pe– anottappaµ pah´naµ atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappaµ pah´naµ atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
11. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit, atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit, atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato dosappahnya –pe– anottappappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit, atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhang bhvit, atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
12. Sadhammakusalo Arah v´targo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-îmant.
- Paradhammakusalo Arah v´targo –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
13. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pah´no, n’atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pah´no, n’atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no –pe– anottappaµ pah´naµ, n’atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no –pe– anottappaµ pah´naµ, n’atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
14. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit–pe–anottappappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit, n’atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-îmant.
- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhang bhvit, n’atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Paradhammakusalo Arah v´targo v´targo v´tadoso v´tamoho–pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, n’atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Sadhammakusalo Arah v´targo –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, n’atthi tassa kankh ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
15. Atthi Arahato kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－ “Jnatvhaµ Bhikkhave passato savnaµ khayaµ vadmi, no ajnato no apassato. Ki� ca Bhikkhave jnato kiµ passato savnaµ khayo hoti ? Iti rèpaµ, iti rèpassa samudaya, iti rèpassa atthangamo; iti vedan –pe– iti sa�� –pe– iti saµkhr –pe– iti vi��naµ, iti vi��nassa samudayo, iti vi��nassa atthangamo ti. Evaµ kho Bhikkhave jnato evaµ passato savnaµ khayo hot´ti.” Atth’eva suttanto ti ?
- îmant.
- Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato kankh ti”
16. Atthi Arahato kankh ti ?
-îmant.
- -Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－ “Jnatvhaµ Bhikkhave passato savnaµ khayaµ vadmi, no ajnato no apassato. Ki� ca Bhikkhave jnato kiµ passato savnaµ khayo hoti ? Idaµ dukkhan ti Bhikkhave ajnato apassato savnaµ khayo hoti, ayaµ dukkhasamudayo ti jnato passato savnaµ khayo hoti, ayaµ dukkhanirodhagmin´pa ipad ti jnato passato savnaµ khayo hoti. Evaµ kho Bhikkhave jnato evaµ passato savnaµ khayo hot´ti.” Atth’eva suttanto ti ?
-îmant.
-Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato kankh ti”
17 Atthi Arahato kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－“Sabbaµ Bhikkhave anabhijnaµ aparijnaµ avirjayaµ appajahaµ abhabbo dukkhkkhyya. Sabba� ca kho Bhikkhave abhijnaµ parijnaµ virjayaµ pajahaµ bhabbo dukkhakkhyyti” Atth’eva suttanto ti ?
-îmant.
-Tena hi na vattabbaµ ‘Atthi Arahato kankh ti”
18. Atthi Arahato kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－
“Sah v’assa dassanasampadya
Tayas su dhamm jahit bhavanti
Sakkyadi hi vicikicchita� ca
S´labbataµ vpi yad atthi ki�ci,
Catèh’ apyehi ca vippamutto
Cha cbhi hnni abhabbo ktun ti”.
-Atth’eva suttanto ti ?
-îmant.
-Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato kankh ti” ?
19. Atthi Arahato kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－“Yasmiµ Bhikkhave samaye ariyasvakassa virajaµ v´tamalaµ dhammacakkhuµ udapdi, ‘yaµ ki�ci samudayadhammaµ sabban taµ nirodhadhamman ti,’ saha dassanuppd Bhikkhave ariyasvakassa t´öi sa��ojaöni pah´yanti, sakkyadi hi vicikicch s´labbataparmso ti.” Atth’eva suttanto ti”
-îmant.
Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato kankh ti” ?
20. Atthi Arahato kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－
“Yad have ptubhavanti dhamm
jhyato brhmanassa,
Ath’assa, kankh vapayanti sabb
Yato pajnti sahetudhamman ti.
Yad have ptubhavanti dhamm
îtpino jhyato brhmanassa,
Ath’assa, kankh vapayanti sabb
Yato khayaµ paccaynaµ aved´ti.
Yad have ptubhavanti dhamm
îtpino jhyato brhmanassa,
Vidhèpayaµ<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[24]<!--[endif]--> ti hati Mrasenaµ
Suriyo<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[25]<!--[endif]--> va obhsayaµ antalikkhan ti.
Y kci kankh idha v huraµ v
Sakavediy<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[26]<!--[endif]--> v paravediy v,
Jhyino<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[27]<!--[endif]--> t pajahanti<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[28]<!--[endif]--> sabb
îtpino brahmacariyaµ carant ti.”
“Ye kankh samatikkant<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[29]<!--[endif]--> kankhbhètessu pnisu
Asaµsay visaµyutt<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[30]<!--[endif]--> tesu dinnaµ mahapphalan ti.”
Etdis´<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[31]<!--[endif]--> dhammapaksanettha<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[32]<!--[endif]-->
Kin nu tattha<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[33]<!--[endif]--> kankhati koci svako,
Nitiööa-oghaµ<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[34]<!--[endif]--> vicikicchachinnaµ<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[35]<!--[endif]-->
Buddhaµ namassma<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[36]<!--[endif]--> jinaµ janind ti.”
Atth’eva suttanto ti ?
-îmant.
-Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato kankh ti” ?
21. Na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato kankh ti.”
-îmant.
-Nanu Arah i hipurisnaµ nmagotte kankheyya, maggmagge kankheyya, tinaka havanappat´naµ nme kankheyyati ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci Arah i hipurisnaµ nmagotte –pe– tinaka havanappat´naµ nme kankheyya, tena vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato kankh ti.”
22. Arah i hipurisnaµ nmagotte –pe– tinaka havanappat´naµ nme kankheyya, atthi Arahato kankh ti. ?
-îmant.
-Arah sotpattiphale v sakadgmiphale v angmiphale v arahatte v kankheyyti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
Kankhkath.
_________________________
II.4
1. Atthi Arahato paravitran<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[37]<!--[endif]--> ti ?
-îmant.
-Arah paraneyyo parapattiyo parapaccayo parapa ibbaddhabbè<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[38]<!--[endif]--> na jnti, na passati, sammuÂho<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[39]<!--[endif]--> asampajno ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Nanu Arah na paraneyyo, na parapattiyo, na parapaccayo, na parapa ibbaddhabbè jnti, passati, sammuÂho asampajno ti ?
-îmant.
- -Ha�ci Arah na paraneyyo, na parapattiyo, na parapaccayo, na parapa ibbaddhabbè jnti, passati, sammuÂho asampajno, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato paravitran ti.”
2. Atthi puthujjanassa paravitran, so ca paraneyyo parapattiyo parapaccayo parapa ibbaddhabbè na jnti, na passati, sammuÂho asampajno ti ?
-îmant.
-Atthi Arahato paravitran, so ca paraneyyo parapattiyo parapaccayo parapa ibbaddhabbè na jnti, na passati, sammuÂho asampajno ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
3. Atthi Arahato paravitran, so ca na paraneyyo na parapattiyo na parapaccayo parapa ibbaddhabbè jnti, passati, sammuÂho asampajno ti ?
-îmant.
-Atthi puthujjanassa paravitran, so ca na paraneyyo na parapattiyo na parapaccayo parapa ibbaddhabbè jnti, passati, sammuÂho asampajno ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
4. Atthi Arahato paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
-Atthi Arahato Satthari paravitran, Dhamme paravitran, Saµghe paravitran, sikya paravitran, pubbante paravitran, aparante paravitran, pubbantparante paravitran, idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu paravitranti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
N’atthi Arahato Satthari paravitran, Dhamme paravitran, Saµghe paravitran, sikya paravitran, pubbante paravitran, aparante paravitran, pubbantparante paravitran, idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci n’atthi Arahato Satthari paravitran, Dhamme paravitran, Saµghe paravitran –pe–idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu paravitran, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato paravitran ti.”
5. Atthi puthujjanassa paravitran, atthi tassa Satthari paravitran, Dhamme paravitran, Saµghe paravitran –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu paravitran ti.?
-îmant.
-Atthi Arahato paravitran, atthi tassa Satthari paravitran, Dhamme paravitran, Saµghe paravitran –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu paravitran ti.?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Atthi Arahato paravitran, n’atthi tassa Satthari paravitran, Dhamme paravitran, Saµghe paravitran –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu paravitran ti.?
-îmant.
-Atthi puthujjanassa paravitran, n’atthi tassa Satthari paravitran, Dhamme paravitran, Saµghe paravitran –pe– idappaccayatpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu paravitran ti.?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
6. Atthi Arahato paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu Arahato rgo pah´no ucchinnamèlo tlvatthukato anabhvaµkato yatiµ anuppdadhammao ti ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci Arahato rgo pah´no ucchinnamèlo tlvatthukato anabhvaµkato yatiµ anuppdadhammao, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato paravitran ti”
-Nanu Arahato doso pah´no –pe– moho pah´no –pe– anottappaµ pah´naµ ucchinnamèlaµ tlvatthukataµ anabhvaµkataµ yatiµ anuppdadhamman ti ?
-îmant.
- Ha�ci Arahato anottappaµ pah´naµ ucchinnamèlaµ tlvatthukataµ anabhvaµkataµ yatiµ anuppdadhammaµ, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato paravitran ti.”
7 Atthi Arahato paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit ti ?
-îmant.
- Ha�ci Arahato rgappahnya bojjhang bhvit, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato paravitran ti.”
-Atthi Arahato paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu Arahato dosoppahnya –pe– anottappappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit ti ?
-îmant.
Ha�ci anottappappahnya bojjhang bhvit, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato paravitran ti.”
8. Atthi Arahato paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
- Nanu Arah v´targo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikatan ti ?
-îmant.
- Ha�ci Arah v´targo –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato paravitran ti.”
9. Atthi Arahato paravitran ti ? Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi kankh, Paradhammakusalassa Arahato atthi paravitran, paradhammakusalassa Arahato n’atthi paravitran ti.
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato atthi paravitran ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
Paradhammakusalassa Arahato n’atthi paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato n’atthi paravitran ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
10. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pah´no, atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pah´no, atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no, moho pah´no –pe– anottappaµ pah´naµ atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappaµ pah´naµ atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
11. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit, atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit, atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato dosappahnya –pe– anottappappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit, atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhang bhvit, atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
12. Sadhammakusalo Arah v´targo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
- Paradhammakusalo Arah v´targo –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
13. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pah´no, n’atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pah´no, n’atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no –pe– anottappaµ pah´naµ, n’atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no –pe– anottappaµ pah´naµ, n’atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
14. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit –pe– anottappappahnya maggo bhvito –pe– bojjhang bhvit, n’atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhang bhvit, n’atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Paradhammakusalo Arah v´targo v´targo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, n’atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
-Sadhammakusalo Arah v´targo –pe– sacchiktabbaµ sacchikataµ, n’atthi tassa paravitran ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
15. Atthi Arahato kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－ “Jnatvhaµ Bhikkhave passato savnaµ khayaµ vadmi, no ajnato no apassato. Ki� ca Bhikkhave jnato kiµ passato savnaµ khayo hoti ? Iti rèpaµ, iti rèpassa samudaya, iti rèpassa atthangamo; iti vedan –pe– iti sa�� –pe– iti saµkhr –pe– iti vi��naµ, iti vi��nassa samudayo, iti vi��nassa atthangamo ti. Evaµ kho Bhikkhave jnato evaµ passato savnaµ khayo hot´ti.” Atth’eva suttanto ti ?
- îmant.
- Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato paravitran ti”
16. Atthi Arahato paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
- Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－ “Jnatvhaµ Bhikkhave passato savnaµ khayaµ vadmi, no ajnato no apassato. Ki� ca Bhikkhave jnato kiµ passato savnaµ khayo hoti ? Idaµ dukkhan ti Bhikkhave ajnato apassato savnaµ khayo hoti, ayaµ dukkhasamudayo ti jnato passato savnaµ khayo hoti, ayaµ dukkhanirodhagmin´pa ipad ti jnato passato savnaµ khayo hoti. Evaµ kho Bhikkhave jnato evaµ passato savnaµ khayo hot´ti.” Atth’eva suttanto ti ?
-îmant.
-Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato paravitran ti”
17 Atthi Arahato paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－“Sabbaµ Bhikkhave anabhijnaµ aparijnaµ avirjayaµ appajahaµ abhabbo dukkhkkhyya. Sabba� ca kho Bhikkhave abhijnaµ parijnaµ virjayaµ pajahaµ bhabbo dukkhakkhyyti” Atth’eva suttanto ti ?
-îmant.
-Tena hi na vattabbaµ ‘Atthi Arahato paravitran ti”
18. Atthi Arahato kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－
“Sah v’assa dassanasampadya
Tayas su dhamm jahit bhavanti
Sakkyadi hi vicikicchita� ca
S´labbataµ vpi yad atthi ki�ci,
Catèh’ apyehi ca vippamutto
Cha cbhi hnni abhabbo ktun ti”.
-Atth’eva suttanto ti ?
-îmant.
-Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato paravitran ti” ?
19. Atthi Arahato kankh ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－“Yasmiµ Bhikkhave samaye ariyasvakassa virajaµ v´tamalaµ dhammacakkhuµ udapdi, ‘yaµ ki�ci samudayadhammaµ sabban taµ nirodhadhamman ti,’ saha dassanuppd Bhikkhave ariyasvakassa t´öi sa��ojaöni pah´yanti, sakkyadi hi vicikicch s´labbataparmso ti.” Atth’eva suttanto ti”
-îmant.
-Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato paravitran ti” ?
20. Atthi Arahato paravitran ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－
“Nhaµ<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[40]<!--[endif]--> gamissmi pamocanya<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[41]<!--[endif]-->
Kathaµkathiµ Dhotaka ka�ci<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[42]<!--[endif]--> loke,
Dhamma� ca se haµ abhijnamno
Evaµ tuvaµ<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[43]<!--[endif]--> oghaµ imaµ tares´ti.
-Atth’eva suttanto ti ?
-îmant.
-Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato paravitran ti” ?
21. Na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato paravitran ti.”
-îmant.
-Nanu Arah i hipurisnaµ nmagottaµ pare vitreyyuµ, maggmaggaµ pare vitreyyuµ, tinaka havanappat´naµ nmaµ pare vitreyyun ti ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci Arahato i hipurisnaµ nmagottaµ pare vitreyyuµ, maggmaggaµ pare vitreyyuµ, tinaka havanappat´naµ nmaµ pare vitreyyuµ, tena vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato paravitran ti.”
22. Arahato i hipurisnaµ nmagottaµ, pare vitreyyuµ, maggmaggaµ pare vitreyyuµ, tinaka havanappat´naµ nmaµ pare vitreyyuµ, atthi Arahato paravitran ti.?
-îmant.
-Arah sotpattiphalam v sakadgmiphalaµ v angmiphalaµ v arahattaµ v pare vityyun ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
Paravitraöakath
______________________
II.5
1. Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Sabbattha<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[44]<!--[endif]--> sampannnaµ atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Sabbattha sampannnaµ atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Sabbattha sampannnaµ atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Sabbasampatt´su atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
2. Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
3. Sampannassa atthi vc, atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Sampannassa atthi kyo, atthi kyabhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Sampannassa kyo, n’atthi kyabhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Sampannassa atthi vc, n’atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
4. Dukkhan ti jnanto dukkhan ti vcaµ bhsat´ti ?
-îmant.
-Samudayo ti jnanto Samudayo ti vcaµ bhsat´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Dukkhan ti jnanto dukkhan ti vcaµ bhsat´ti ?
-îmant.
-Nirodho ti jnanto nirodho ti vcaµ bhsat´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Dukkhan ti jnanto dukkhan ti vcaµ bhsat´ti ?
-îmant.
-Maggo ti jnanto maggo ti vcaµ bhsat´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
5. Samudayo ti jnanto na ca samudayo ti vcaµ bhsat´ti ?
-îmant.
- Dukkhan ti jnanto na ca dukkhan ti vcaµ bhsat´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Nirodho ti jnanto na ca nirodho ti vcaµ bhsat´ti ?
-îmant.
-Dukkhan ti jnanto na ca dukkhan ti vcaµ bhsat´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Maggo ti jnanto na ca maggo ti vcaµ bhsat´ti ?
-îmant.
- Dukkhan ti jnanto na ca dukkhan ti vcaµ bhsat´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
6. Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
- Nöaµ kiµgocaran ti ?
- Nöaµ saccagocaran ti ?
-Sotaµ saccagocaran ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Sotaµ kiµgocaran ti ?
Nöaµ saddagocaran ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
7. Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo , �öaµ accagocaraµ, sotaµ saddagocaran ti ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci �öaµ saccagocaraµ, sampannassa sotaµ saddagocaraµ, no vata re vattabbe “Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti.”
-Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo, �öaµ saccagocaraµ, sotaµ saddagocaraµ ti ?
-îmant.
-Dvinnaµ phassnaµ dvinnaµ vedannaµ dvinnaµ sa��naµ dvinnaµ cetannaµ dvinnaµ cittnaµ samodhnaµ hot´ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
8. Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Pa hav´kasiöaµ sampattiµ<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[45]<!--[endif]--> sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-îpokasiöaµ –pe– tejokasiöaµ, vyokasiöaµ, n´lakasiöaµ, p´kakasiöaµ, lohikasiöaµ, odtakasiöaµ, sampattiµ –pe– ksna�cyataöaµ, vi��na�cyataöaµ, ki��yataöaµ –pe– navasa��nsa��yataöaµ sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
9. Pa hav´kasiöaµ sampattiµ sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci pa hav´kasiöaµ sampattiµ sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo, no vata re vattabbe “Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti.”
-îpokasiöaµ –pe– odtakasiöaµ, sampattiµ –pe– ksna�cyataöaµ, vi��na�cyataöaµ, ki��yataöaµ –pe– navasa��nsa��yataöaµ sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci nevasa��nsa��yataöaµ sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo, no vata re vattabbe “Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti.”
10. Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Lokiyaµ sampattiµ sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Lokiyaµ pa hamaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
- Lokiyaµ dutiyaµ jhnaµ –pe– tatiyaµ jhnaµ –pe– catutthaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
11. Lokiyaµ sampattiµ sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci lokiyaµ sampattiµ sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo, no vata re vattabbe “Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti.”
- Lokiyaµ pa hamaµ jhnaµ<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[46]<!--[endif]--> sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci lokiyaµ sampattiµ jhnaµ sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo, no vata re vattabbe “Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti.”
- Lokiyaµ dutiyaµ –pe– catutthaµ jhnaµ sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci lokiyaµ dutiyaµ –pe– catutthaµ jhnaµ sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo, no vata re vattabbe “Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti.”
12. Lokuttaraµ pa hamaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
- Lokiyaµ pa hamaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Lokuttaraµ pa hamaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Lokiyaµ dutiyaµ –pe– tatiyaµ –pe– catutthaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Lokiyaµ pa hamaµ jhnaµ sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
- Lokuttaraµ pa hamaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Lokiyaµ dutiyaµ –pe– catutthaµ jhnaµ sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
- Lokuttaraµ pa hamaµ jhnaµ sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
13. Lokuttaraµ pa hamaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
- Lokuttaraµ dutiyaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Lokuttaraµ pa hamaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Lokiyaµ tatiyaµ –pe– catutthaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Lokuttaraµ dutiyaµ jhnaµ sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
- Lokuttaraµ pa hamaµ jhnaµ sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Lokuttaraµ tatiyaµ –pe– catutthaµ jhnaµ sampannassa n’ atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
- Lokuttaraµ pa hamaµ jhnaµ sampannassa n’atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
14. Na vattabbaµ “Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti.”
-îmant.
- Nanu vitakkavicr vac´saµkhr vutt Bhagavat, pa hanaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vitakkavicr ti ?
- îmant.
- Ha�ci vitakkavicr vac´saµkhr vutt Bhagavat, pa hanaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vitakkavicr, tena vata re vattabbe “Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti.”
15. Vitakkavicr vac´saµkhr vutt Bhagavat, pa hanaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vitakkavicr, atthi tassa vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-pa hav´kasiöaµ pa hamaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vitakkavicr, atthi tassa vac´bhedo ti ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-Vitakkavicr vac´saµkhr vutt Bhagavat, pa hanaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vitakkavicr, atthi tassa vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-îpokasiöaµ –pe– tejokasiöaµ, vyokasiöaµ, n´lakasiöaµ, p´kakasiöaµ, lohikasiöaµ –pe– odtakasiöaµ pa hanaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vitakkavicr, atthi tassa vac´bhedo ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
16.Na vattabbaµ “Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti.”
-îmant.
- Nanu vitakkasamu hn<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[47]<!--[endif]--> vc vutt Bhagavat, pa hanaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vitakkavicr ti ?
- îmant.
- Ha�ci vitakkasamu hn vc vutt Bhagavat, pa hanaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vitakkavicr, tena vata re vattabbe “Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti.”
- 17. Vitakkasamu hn vc vutt Bhagavat, pa hanaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vitakkavicr, atthi tassa vac´bhedo ti ?
- îmant.
-Sa��samu hn vc vutt Bhagavat, dutiynaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi sa��, atthi tassa vitakkavicr ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Vitakkasamu hn vc vutt Bhagavat, pa hanaµ jhnaµ sampannassa atthi vitakkavicr, atthi tassa vac´bhedo ti ?
- îmant.
-Sa��samu hn vc vutt Bhagavat, tatiynaµ jhnaµ –pe– catutthaµ jhnaµ, ksna�cyataöaµ, vi��na�cyataöaµ, ki��yataöaµ sampannassa atthi sa��, atthi tassa vitakkavicr ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
18. Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
-Nanu “pa hamaµ jhnaµ sampannassa vc nirodh hot´ti,” atth’eva suttanto ti ?
-îmant.
- Ha�ci “pa hamaµ jhnaµ sampannassa vc nirodh hot´ti,” atth’eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe “Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti.”
19. “pa hamaµ jhnaµ sampannassa vc nirudh hot´ti,” atth’eva suttanto ti , atthi tassaa vic´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
Dutiyaµ jhnaµ sampannassa vitakkavicr nirudh hot´ti,” atth’eva suttanto ti, atthi tassaa vitakkavicr ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
-“pa hamaµ jhnaµ sampannassa vc nirudh hot´ti,” atth’eva suttanto ti , atthi tassaa vic´bhedo ti ?
-îmant.
“Tatiyaµ jhnaµ sampannassa p´ti<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[48]<!--[endif]--> nirudh hot´ –pe– catutthaµ jhnaµ sampannassa asssapass nirudh honti, ksna�cyataöaµ sampannassa rèpa sa�� nirudh hoti, vi��na�cyataöaµ sampannassa ksna�cyataöaµ nirudh hoti, ki��yataöaµ sampannassa nirudh hoti –pe– nevasa��sa��yataöaµ sampannassa ksna�cyataöaµ nirudh hoti, sa��vedayitanirodhaµ sampannassa sa�� ca vedan ca niruddh hont´ti.” atth’eva suttanto ti , atthi tassaa sa�� ca vedan c ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
20. Na vattabbaµ “sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti” ?
- îmant.
Nanu pa hamassa jhnassa saddo kaö hako<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[49]<!--[endif]--> vutto Bhagavat ti ?
-îmant.
-Ha�ci pa hamassa jhnassa saddo kaö hako vutto Bhagavat, tena vata re vattabbe “Sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti.”
21. Pa hamassa jhnassa saddo kaö hako vutto Bhagavat ti, sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti.?
-îmant.
-Dutiyassa jhnassa vitakkavicr kaö hako vutto Bhagavat –pe– tatiyassa jhnassa p´ti kaö hako vutto Bhagavat –pe– catutthassa jhnassa asssapasss kaö hako vutt Bhagavat, ksna�cyataöaµ sampannassa rèpasa�� kaö hako vutto Bhagavat, vi��na�cyataöaµ sampannassa ksna�cyataöaµ kaö hako vutto Bhagavat, ki�ca�n��yataöaµ sampannassa vi��öa�cyatanasa�� kaö hako vutto Bhagavat, nevasa��sa��yataöaµ sampannassa ki�ca��yatanasa�� kaö hako vutto Bhagavat –pe– sa��vedayitanirodhaµ sampannassa sa�� ca vedan ca kaö hako vutto Bhagavat, atthi tassaa sa�� ca vedan c ti ?
-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
22. Na vattabbaµ “sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti” ?
- îmant.
-Nanu vuttaµ Bhagavat－ “Sikhissa înanda Bhagavato Arahato Sammsambuddhassa abhibhè nama svako brahmaloke hito sahassilokadhtuµ<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[50]<!--[endif]--> sarena vi��pesi.
îrabbhatha nikkamatha
Yu�jatha<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[51]<!--[endif]--> Buddhassane,
Dhuntha maccuno senaµ
NaÂgraµ<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[52]<!--[endif]--> va ku�jaro.
Yo imasmiµ dhammavinaye
Appamatto viharissati,
Pahya <!--[if !supportFootnotes]--> [53]<!--[endif]-->jtisaµsraµ
Dukkhass’antaµ karissat´ti.”
Atth’eva suttanto ti
-îmant.
-Tena hi sampannassa atthi vac´bhedo ti.
Vac´bhedakath
II.6
1. Dukkhhro maggangaµ maggapariypannan ti ?
-îmant.
- Ye keci “dukkhan ti” vcaµ bhsanti, sabbe te maggaµ bhvent´ti ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Ye keci “dukkhan ti” vcaµ bhsanti, sabbe te maggaµ bhvent´ti ?
- îmant.
- Blaputhujjan “dukkhan ti” vcaµ bhsanti, blaputhujjan te maggaµ bhvent´ti ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
- Mtughtak –pe– pitughtak, arahantaghtak, rèhiruppdak<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->[54]<!--[endif]--> –pe– saµghabhedak “dukkhan ti” vcaµ bhsanti, saµghabhedak maggaµ bhvent´ti ?
- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–
Dukkhhrakath
_____________________________________
阿毘達磨大毘婆沙論卷第九十九
a.
五百大阿羅漢等造
三藏法師玄奘奉 詔譯
智蘊第三中五種納息第二之三
如《契經》說，佛告梵志：若有沙門、婆羅門等，捨惡見趣而不取者，當知此類，少中復少。
問：此類云何少中復少？
答：世間有情，性愚鈍者，如大地土﹔性聰慧者，如爪上土。性聰慧中，邪見者多，正見者少，喻如前說，是故名為「少中復少」。
問：如〈見蘊〉說斷、常見者，展轉相違。云何此中說有一類起如是見？我一分忍，一分不忍，而不相違。
答：此中說：一補特伽羅。若執色蘊為常，彼執四蘊為斷，若執四蘊為常，彼執色蘊為斷。故此二見，非互相違。〈見蘊〉說二補特伽羅。一執色常，一執色斷，乃至執識，亦有二種，故彼二見，展轉相違。
彼經復說：世尊說此見趣法時，長爪梵志遠塵離垢，於諸法中生淨法眼。時，舍利子受具足戒已經半月，隨觀此法得阿羅漢。
問：時，舍利子隨觀何法？
尊者世友作如是說：尊者舍利子，即隨觀世尊為彼梵志說見趣法，成阿羅漢。
復有說者：尊者舍利子，即隨觀梵志得預流果道所觀法，成阿羅漢。
有作是說：尊者舍利子，即隨觀梵志得預流果能證學法，成阿羅漢。
大德說曰：彼舍利子，隨觀緣起有十二支差別性法，成阿羅漢，是名舍利子所隨觀法。
諸起此見：有阿羅漢，天魔所嬈，漏失不淨，乃至廣說。
問：何故作此論？
答：為欲分別佛涅槃後，假名苾芻所起惡見，令有智者知而制之，故作斯論。
(問:)1.諸起此見：有阿羅漢天魔所嬈，漏失不淨。此於五見，何見攝？見何諦斷此見耶？
答：非因計因戒禁取攝，見苦所斷。
此中，非因計因者。謂：彼不淨從煩惱生，而說天魔所嬈故出。故戒禁取以為自性，見苦所斷，顯彼對治。苦智生時，能斷如是不實推求，不實分別，顛倒惡見，令永滅故名「見苦斷」。廣說如前。
(問:)2.諸起此見：有阿羅漢於自解脫，猶有無知。此於五見何見攝？見何諦斷此見耶？
答：謗阿羅漢無漏智見。邪見攝，見道所斷。
此中，謗阿羅漢無漏智見者。謂：阿羅漢於自解脫，由無漏智見，已離無知，而說猶有無知，則撥無彼無漏智見。是故邪見以為自性，見道所斷，顯彼對治。道智生時，能斷如是不實推求，乃至廣說如前應知。
(問:)3.諸起此見：有阿羅漢於自解脫，猶有疑惑。此於五見何見攝？見何諦斷此見耶？
答：謗阿羅漢越渡疑惑。邪見攝，見道所斷。
此中，謗阿羅漢越渡疑惑者。謂：阿羅漢於自解脫，由無漏道已斷疑惑，而說猶有疑惑，則撥無彼道，是故邪見以為自性，見道所斷，顯彼對治。道智生時，能斷如是不實推求，乃至廣說，如前應知。
(問:)4.諸起此見：有阿羅漢，但由他度。此於五見何見攝？見何諦斷此見耶？
答：謗阿羅漢無障，無背，現量慧眼，身證自在。邪見攝，見道所斷。
此中，謗阿羅漢無障，無背，現量慧眼，身證自在者。謂：阿羅漢實自證得無障，無背，現量慧眼，身證自在。非但由他而得度脫，然說但由他故得度，則謗聖道。是故邪見以為自性，見道所斷，顯彼對治。道智生時，能斷如是不實推求，乃至廣說，如前應知。
(問:)5.諸起此見：道及道支苦言所召。此於五見何見攝？見何諦斷此見耶？
答：非因計因戒禁取攝，見苦所斷。
此中，非因計因者。謂：諸聖道要修方得，而說苦言能召令起，故戒禁取以為自性，見苦所斷，顯彼對治。苦智生時，能斷如是不實推求，乃至廣說，如前應知。此於苦果，計為道因，故見苦時，永斷此見。
已說五種惡見自性及彼對治。等起云何？
謂：大天因緣是此等起。
昔，末土羅國（Mathura）有一商主，少娉妻室，生一男兒，顏容端正，與字大天（Mahādeva）。未久之間，商主持寶，遠適他國，展轉貿易，經久不還。其子長大，染穢於母。後聞父還，心既怖懼，與母設計，遂殺其父。彼既造一無間業已。
事漸彰露，便將其母，展轉逃隱波吒梨城(Pātaḷputra)。彼後遇逢本國所供養阿羅漢苾芻，復恐事彰，遂設方計殺彼苾芻，既造第二無間業已。
心轉憂慼，後復見母與餘交通，便憤恚言：我為此故造二重罪，移流他國[跳-兆+令]跰不安。今復捨我，更好他人，如是倡穢，誰堪容忍。於是方便，復殺其母，彼造第三無間業已。
由彼不斷善根力故，深生憂悔，寢處不安，自惟重罪，何緣當滅？
彼後傳聞沙門釋子有滅罪法，遂往雞園僧伽藍所。於其門外，見一苾芻徐步經行，誦伽他曰：
若人造重罪 修善以滅除
彼能照世間 如月出雲翳
時彼聞已，歡喜勇躍，知歸佛教，定能滅罪。因即往詣一苾芻所，慇懃固請，求度出家。
時，彼苾芻既見固請，不審撿問，遂度出家，還字大天，教授教誡。大天聰慧，出家未久，便能誦持三藏文義，言詞清巧，善能化導，波吒梨城，無不歸仰。
王聞召請，數入內宮，恭敬供養，而請說法。彼後既出在僧伽藍，不正思惟，夢失不淨，然彼先稱是阿羅漢，而令弟子浣所污衣。
弟子白言：阿羅漢者，諸漏已盡，師今何容，猶有斯事？
大天告言：天魔所嬈，汝不應怪。然所漏失，略有二種：一者、煩惱，二者、不淨。煩惱漏失，阿羅漢無，猶未能免，不淨漏失。所以者何？諸阿羅漢煩惱雖盡，豈 無便利、涕、唾等事。然諸天魔，常於佛法而生憎嫉，見修善者，便往壞之。縱阿羅漢，亦為其嬈，故我漏失，是彼所為。汝今不應有所疑怪。是名第一惡見等起。
又，彼大天欲令弟子歡喜親附，矯設方便，次第記別四沙門果。時，彼弟子稽首白言：阿羅漢等應有證智，如何我等都不自知？
彼遂告言：諸阿羅漢亦有無知，汝今不應於己不信。謂：諸無知略有二種：一者、染污，阿羅漢已無，二者、不染污，阿羅漢猶有。由此汝輩不能自知。是名第二惡見等起。
時，諸弟子復白彼言：曾聞聖者已度疑惑，如何我等於諦實中猶懷疑惑？
彼復告言：諸阿羅漢亦有疑惑，疑有二種：一者、隨眠性疑，阿羅漢已斷。二者、處非處疑，阿羅漢未斷。獨覺於此而猶成就，況汝聲聞於諸諦實能無疑惑而自輕耶？是名第三惡見等起。
後彼弟子披讀諸經，說阿羅漢有聖慧眼，於自解脫，能自證知。
因白師言：我等若是阿羅漢者，應自證知，如何但由師之令入，都無現智能自證知？
彼即答言：有阿羅漢但由他入，不能自知。如舍利子，智慧第一，大目乾連，神通第一。佛若未記，彼不自知，況由他入，而能自了。故汝於此，不應窮詰。是名第四惡見等起。
然彼大天雖造眾惡，而不斷滅諸善根故。後於中夜，自惟罪重，當於何處受諸劇苦，憂惶所逼，數唱：「苦哉！」。
近住弟子，聞之驚怪，晨朝參問：起居安不？
大天答言：吾甚安樂。
弟子尋白：若爾昨夜何唱「苦哉！」？
彼遂告言：我呼聖道，汝不應怪。謂：諸聖道若不至誠稱苦，召命終不現起，故我昨夜，數唱：「苦哉！」。是名第五惡見等起。
大天於後，集先所說，五惡見事，而作頌言：
餘所誘無知 猶豫他令入
道因聲故起 是名真佛教
於後漸次雞園寺中，上座苾芻多皆滅歿，十五日夜布灑他時，次當大天昇座說戒，彼便自誦所造伽他。爾時眾中有學、無學、多聞、持戒修靜慮者，聞彼所說，無不驚訶：「咄哉！愚人寧作是說。此於三藏，曾所未聞。」
咸即對之翻彼頌曰：
餘所誘無知 猶豫他令入
道因聲故起 汝言非佛教
於是竟夜鬥諍紛然，乃至終朝，朋黨轉盛。城中士庶，乃至大臣，相次來和，皆不能息。王聞自出，詣僧伽藍，於是兩朋各執己誦。時，王聞已亦自生疑，尋白大天，孰非誰是，我等今者，當寄何朋？
大天白王：戒經中說，若欲滅諍，依多人語。
王遂令僧，兩朋別住。賢聖朋內，耆年雖多，而僧數少;大天朋內，耆年雖少，而眾數多。王遂從多，依大天眾，訶伏餘眾，事畢還宮。
爾時，雞園諍猶未息，後隨異見遂分二部：
一、上座部。
二、大眾部。
時，諸賢聖知眾乖違，便捨雞園，欲往他處。諸臣聞已，遂速白王，王聞既瞋，便敕臣曰：宜皆引至殑伽河邊，載以破船，中流墜溺，即驗斯輩，是聖是凡。
臣奉王言，便將驗試。時，諸賢聖各起神通，猶如雁王，陵虛而往。復以神力，攝取船中同捨雞園未得通者，現諸神變，作種種形相，次乘空西北而去。王聞見已，深生愧悔，悶絕[跳-兆+辟]地水灑乃蘇。速即遣人，尋其所趣，使還，知在迦濕彌羅，復固請還，僧皆辭命。
王遂總捨迦濕彌羅國，造僧伽藍，安置賢聖眾，隨先所變作種種形，即以摽題僧伽藍號，謂：雞園等數有五百。復遣使人，多齎珍寶，營辦什物而供養之，由是爾來，此國多有諸賢聖眾，任持佛法，相傳制造，于今猶盛。
波吒梨王既失彼眾，相率供養住雞園僧。於後，大天因遊城邑，有占相者，遇爾見之，竊記彼言：今此釋子，卻後七日，定當命終。
弟子聞之，憂惶啟告，彼便報曰：吾已久知。
還至雞園遣諸弟子，分散遍告波吒梨城：王及諸臣、長者、居士！卻後七日，吾當涅槃。
王等聞之，無不傷歎，至第七日，彼遂命終。王及諸臣，城中士庶，悲哀戀慕，各辦香薪，并諸酥油，花香等物，積置一處，而焚葬之。持火來燒，隨至隨滅，種種方計，竟不能然。
有占相師謂眾人曰：彼不消此殊勝葬具，宜以狗糞而灑穢之。
便用其言，火遂炎發。須臾，焚蕩俄成灰燼，暴風卒至，飄散無遺。
故彼是前惡見等起，諸有智者，應知避之。
Tài liệu tham khảo:
1. HT. Minh Châu dịch, “Kinh Tương Ưng Bộ” tập 2, Viện NCPHVN ấn hành.
2. HT. Minh Châu dịch, “Kinh Trung Bộ” tập 1,2,3, Viện NCPHVN ấn hành.
3. Viện CĐPHHĐNT dịch, “Kinh Tạp A Hàm” tập 1,2 Viện NCPHVN ấn hành.
4. Viện CĐPHHĐNT dịch, “Kinh Trung A Hàm” tập 1,4 Viện NCPHVN Ấn hành.
5. “Kinh Diệu Pháp Liên Hoa”, ĐT 09.
6. “Xá Lợi Phất A Tỳ Đàm Luận” ĐT 28.
7. “Dị Bộ Tôn Luân Luận”, ĐT 49.
8. “Đại Tỳ Bà Sa Luận” ĐT 27.
9. “Kathvatthu” The Pali Text Society, London 1979.
10. Ấn Thuận, “Nguyên Thủy Phật giáo Thánh Điển chi Tập thành” NXB Chánh Văn, Taipei 1993.
11. Ấn Thuận, “Sơ Kỳ Đại Thừa Phật giáo chi khởi nguyên dữ khai triển”, NXB Chánh Văn, Taipei 1993.
12. Ấn Thuận “Nghiên cứu về Duy thức học” NXB Chánh Văn, Taipei 1997.
13. HT Ấn Thuận “Thắng Man Kinh Giảng Ký”, NXB Chánh Văn, Taipei 1997.
14. Thích Tâm Minh, “A Dục Vương cuộc đời và sự nghiệp”, NXB Tôn giáo, Hà Nội, 2004.
15. Ấn Thuận “Hoa Vũ Tập” Q.4 NXB Chánh Văn, Taipei, 1999.
16. André Bareau, Pháp Hiền dịch, “Các bộ phái Phật giáo Tiểu thừa” NXB Tôn giáo, Hà Nội 2002.
17. Lữ Trưng “Ấn độ Phật học tư tưởng khái luận” NXB Thiên Hoa, Taipei năm 1997.
18. Pháp sư Diễn Bồi, “Dị Bộ Tôn Luân Luận Ngữ Thể Thích” Taipei, NXB Thiên Hoa, 1974.
19. Tỷ kheo Thích Thiện Minh dịch, “Chú giải thuyết Luận sự”(Kathāvatthu-atthākathā), trang Web: www.phatgiaonguyenthuy.com
<!--[if !supportFootnotes]-->
<!--[endif]-->
(Tải xuống font chữ cần thiết để xem chú thích Pali trong sách này)